Why can Bread & Butter track a lead's full journey for years, when CRMs and cookie-based tools lose the trail after a few months?
Most CRMs and marketing tools reconstruct a lead's history from cookies, and cookies were never built to last. Bread & Butter takes a different approach, one that holds up long after any browser-set cookie would have expired.
Bread & Butter keeps one profile for years, while cookies and analytics forget in months
Why Cookie-Based Tools Lose the Trail

In short: Most CRMs and marketing tools rely on cookies that were never built to last. HubSpot's own attribution cookies expire after six months by default, and browsers cap cookie lifespan even further: Safari limits script-set first-party cookies to seven days, and Chrome caps every cookie at 400 days, roughly 13 months. Google Analytics 4 keeps its user-level data for 2 or 14 months, depending on the setting. Bread & Butter isn't limited by any of that, because once a visitor is verified their full journey is tied to their profile rather than to a cookie that is built to expire. The moment someone raises a hand, through a form, a newsletter, a checkout or one click, every visit before and after lands on the same profile, however long they take to decide. Retention extends to years, not months, and on the Pro Plus plan your data never expires.
Most CRMs and marketing platforms track visitors using cookies that were never built to last.
HubSpot's own documentation lists its analytics cookies, hubspotutk and __hstc , as expiring in six months. That is actually generous compared to what browsers now allow.
Safari's Intelligent Tracking Prevention caps script-set first-party cookies at seven days. Apple's WebKit team announced the change in March 2020, applying it to all script-writable storage including LocalStorage, IndexedDB and Service Worker caches, not just cookies.
Chrome went further in a different direction. Since Chrome 104, released in August 2022, no cookie can set an expiration date more than 400 days in the future. As Google's own developer documentation puts it, "cookies can no longer set an expiration date more than 400 days in the future." A cookie that asks for longer is not rejected, it is silently capped.
Google Analytics has a shorter limit of its own. On the standard version of Google Analytics 4, the user-level and event-level data behind its explorations and funnel reports is kept for either 2 months or 14 months, and never longer (Google). GA4 also doesn't allow email addresses or other personal details to be sent to it (Google), so it can't hold a named person's journey at all.
However a tool is configured, the trail eventually breaks. Not from bad design, but because the browser itself won't hold onto it any longer.
| What sets the limit | How long the trail survives |
|---|---|
HubSpot analytics cookies (hubspotutk , __hstc ) |
6 months |
| Safari ITP, script-set first-party cookies | 7 days |
| Chrome, every cookie | 400 days (about 13 months) |
| Google Analytics 4, user-level data | 2 or 14 months |
| Bread & Butter, verified identity | Not cookie-dependent, kept for years |
How Bread & Butter Keeps the Full Picture
Bread & Butter doesn't depend on a single cookie surviving for years, because no cookie can. Once a visitor is verified, through a form submission, a subscribe widget, or an authenticated social login, that identity becomes the anchor instead of the cookie.
Every session tied to that profile, past and future, gets reconstructed against that same verified identity, whether the person returns next week or years later, long after any original cookie would have expired.
Related
- What is Bread & Butter and why should I install it on my website?
- What is Focused Score and how does it evaluate my traffic?
- Why Marketers Need Unified Subdomain Tracking
- How do I use the Attribution Report to optimize my marketing budget?
- The Intelligence Brief: Living Context in the Tools Your Team Already Uses
- How do Lead Stages work in Bread & Butter, and why does marking Won/Closed matter?
Sources
- Cookie Expires and Max-Age attributes now have upper limit, Chrome for Developers
- Full Third-Party Cookie Blocking and More, WebKit, March 2020
- What cookies does HubSpot set in a visitor's browser?, HubSpot Knowledge Base
- Data retention, Google Analytics Help
- Sending personal information to Google Analytics, Google Analytics Help